I caught a few moments of The Wright Stuff this morning just as they began talking about Jimmy Carr and a story I wasn't aware of. In one of his stand up shows, Jimmy mad a gag about amputee soldiers. To paraphrase, the joke went along the lines of - one thing you can say about all the amputee soldiers is we're going to have a hell of a paralympic squad in 2010.
Some media, politicians and commentators have lept on this with some seemingly wanting to amputate Jimmy's head.
The debate on The Wright Stuff mainly concentrated on a few of themes, those who thought it was shameless and distasteful, those who believe comedy must stretch all boundaries of taste (and with Jimmy's material you get what you expect) and others saying it was an extension of a type of dark and self deprecating humour often observed in such areas as the forces (indeed some quarters suggest Jimmy got the joke from amputee soldiers themselves whom he has visited).
It was even suggested that Jimmy's joke was in a roundabout way a compliment to the soldiers.
My take is that if the joke is on anyone, it is on us - the general public. It was an uncomfortable joke because it made us uncomfortable. For all our oohing and ahhing over our forces involvement in Afghanistan and Iraq how many of us know the real casualty numbers? The media picks up the highly emotive deaths, but bar the odd late night documentary, how many of us now just how many of our soldiers and armed forces are coming back with horrendous injuries. Some will argue it's a fruitless war, others will argue soldiers know what they are signing up for. Whilst all these people are arguing (from the comfort of their own homes), real people are coming back to face a new reality of disability.
I know people in the armed forces and people who have worked the medical units in Afghanistan, the number is staggering and the number is rising. Over 230 soldiers have been seriously injured this year alone. Hundreds of patients - UK troops, Nato troops and Afghans - go through the army medical unit each month.
Now put the joke in context - translate it, why are we going to have one hell of a paralympic team? Because we have hundreds of men and women coming home severely injured - that is the true point of the joke.
And today we are talking about the issue because a one sentence joke, which made you take a sharp intake of breath, reminded you of a cold hard truth. A politician hasn't put this back on the agenda, a heartfelt documentary didn't make us sit up and listen. A comedian, who has taken the time out to visit these men and women, cut us straight to the quick. Many a true word said in jest. Comedy has many powers, and this is one of them.
So the likes of MPs who are calling for Jimmy to be dragged across the coals add this sick joke to your list - I'm so glad you are up in arms about this and so glad you have 2 arms to up in unlike some of our soldiers. Now kindly piss off and do something truly useful for our troops instead of flapping your mouths.
Recent Comments